Semifinalists Show that There’s No Place Like Home When You’re Picking Your Team
The collective wisdom is that it’s good for a national team to have players playing in the big leagues outside their own country. If your players are good enough to get noticed by, say, the English Premier League, it means they’re extremely good. And that can only be good for the national team. Right?
Egypt shattered that belief in the African Cup of Nations this year, demolishing star-heavy, European-based teams like Ivory Coast on their way to winning the Cup. I remember noticing in Egypt’s first game that they were already playing cohesively, like a team that had spent a lot of time on the field together. And I also noticed that the vast majority of their players plied their trade in the Egyptian league.
The Euros are also proving that there’s no place like home for picking a squad, at least in the knockout stages. In each of the first three games, the teams with the most domestic players went through. The teams with the most foreign-based players went home. (In the Italy-Spain game, the majority of players on both teams play domestically, so this wasn’t an issue.)
Here are the stats, based on the 23-player final squad lists. (And this is just based on quick-and-dirty Wikipedia flag-counting, so I’m not guaranteeing that it’s 100% accurate. But it’s definitely close enough to draw conclusions.):
QF Winners All less than 25% playing outside the country
Russia — 1 player playing outside of the country
Turkey – 5 players playing outside of the country
Germany — 3 players playing outside of the country
Spain – 5 players playing outside of the country*
QF Losers:
Netherlands — 14 players playing outside of the country
Croatia — 22 players playing outside of the country
Portugal — 12 players playing outside of the country
Italy — 4 players playing outside of the country*
Of course, we only have to look at England to see that this isn’t definitive. In England’s current squad, only David Beckham plays abroad. And we know all how far that got them.
There are also plenty of other factors affecting how teams play in tournaments. For example having a player on the roster of a huge club doesn’t mean that player is seeing time on the field.
But I’m curious as to what you think about this. High percentage of domestic players: Statistical anomaly, or competitive advantage?
*In the Italy-Spain game, both teams have less than 25% of the squad playing outside of the country, so this was not an issue in that game.
Related Posts
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
|
Comments


I think it’s true that having several players who play for the same TEAM xcan be an advantage. I don’t have any stats like youn to back me up, but it stands to reason that if your centre back pairing, or your strikers, play together week in week out then they will have a better understanding.
Oh and England are not an anomoly - we’re just plain rubbish!




I don’t know if it’s anything other than statistical noise.
The World Cup ‘06 semifinals had France (12 players abroad), Portugal (15 players), Germany (2 players), and Italy (0 players abroad).
The Euro ‘04 semis had Portugal (7 players abroad), Netherlands (17 players), Czech Republic (18 players), and Greece (8 players abroad).
I think your evidence shows that the Russian league is underrated (UEFA Cup winners, Euro semifinalist), that the Bundesliga and La Liga are top quality leagues (no suprise), and Turkey is cinderella (they didn’t so much as qualify for the ‘06 WC or Euro ‘04).
Also arguing against your thesis is Croatia. I thought they played very much like a team in this tournament with lots of cohesion. They just came up empty in PKs in a crazy match.
My conclusion is good coaches with great young players succeed (Germany, Spain, Russia) and a gritty team playing hard can make it’s own luck in a short tournament (Turkey).
Posted from
United States




To add to the noise: another theory is that all teams who rested their A-squad in the final group game struggled and lost their rhythm. Three out of four.




Jan, a whole post about that phenomenon is on the way later today.
Posted from
United Kingdom




Boycott the 2010 World Cup. Let your voice be heard! http://zimsolidarity.blogspot.com/
Posted from
United States


Comments are closed
Send Your Tips!
Email tips[at]worldcupblog[dot]org
Euro 2008 Club Football News
- Daily Dose: Nov 19th, 2008
- When Flip Throw-Ins Go Wrong
- Jogi Won't Give Jens His Tribute, So Rene Adler Does.
- UEFA Want Your Skill Submissions; Hideous Prize Awaits.
- The 10 Richest Men in Soccer (According to Forbes)
More Euro 2008 Blogs
Austria World Cup Blog
101 Articles | 113 Comments
Croatia World Cup Blog
170 Articles | 1,716 Comments
Czech Republic World Cup Blog
196 Articles | 319 Comments
France World Cup Blog
720 Articles | 8,359 Comments
Germany World Cup Blog Blog
442 Articles | 2,818 Comments
Greece World Cup Blog
95 Articles | 47 Comments
Italy World Cup Blog
438 Articles | 15,690 Comments
Netherlands World Cup Blog
1,515 Articles | 15,870 Comments
Poland World Cup Blog
248 Articles | 1,723 Comments
Portugal World Cup Blog
424 Articles | 6,452 Comments
Romania World Cup Blog
66 Articles | 275 Comments
Russia World Cup Blog
44 Articles | 109 Comments
Spain World Cup Blog
197 Articles | 1,516 Comments
Sweden World Cup Blog
150 Articles | 318 Comments
Switzerland World Cup Blog
216 Articles | 327 Comments
Turkey World Cup Blog
31 Articles | 271 Comments
UEFA Euro 2008 Championships
546 Articles | 7,250 Comments
Monthly Archives
World 










